Practice Debating Ethical Scenarios
Scenario: A company decides to replace human workers with AI to increase efficiency. Debate the ethical implications of this decision.
Argument For:
The company has a responsibility to stay competitive and provide the best service possible.
Argument Against:
Replacing human workers with AI could lead to massive unemployment and social inequality.
Scenario: Governments should have the right to access personal data to prevent terrorism. Is this ethical?
Argument For:
National security is paramount, and accessing data can help prevent attacks.
Argument Against:
This violates individual privacy rights and can lead to abuse of power.
Scenario: Is it ethical for companies to use animal testing for product safety?
Argument For:
Ensuring product safety for humans is crucial, and animal testing is a necessary step.
Argument Against:
Animal testing is cruel and unnecessary with modern alternatives available.
Scenario: Should wealthy nations be obligated to help poorer countries deal with climate change?
Argument For:
Wealthy nations have the resources and responsibility to assist, especially since they contribute more to global pollution.
Argument Against:
Each country should focus on its own problems; resources are limited.
Scenario: Is it ethical for parents to monitor their children’s online activities without their consent?
Argument For:
Parents have a responsibility to protect their children from online dangers.
Argument Against:
Children deserve privacy, and monitoring could damage trust.
Remember, in ethical debates, there isn’t a single correct answer. The goal is to present a well-reasoned argument supported by evidence and logical reasoning.
Discussion Points:
AI vs. Human Workers:
For: Efficiency, cost savings, technological progress.
Against: Social responsibility, job loss, economic impact.
Government Data Access:
For: National security, prevention of terrorism, greater good.
Against: Privacy invasion, potential for abuse, ethical boundaries.
Animal Testing:
For: Human safety, scientific progress.
Against: Cruelty, availability of alternatives, ethical progress.
Climate Change Responsibility:
For: Global cooperation, shared responsibility, historical accountability.
Against: National focus, resource allocation, sovereign rights.
Parental Monitoring:
For: Child safety, parental duty.
Against: Privacy rights, trust issues, autonomy.