Making ethical decisions involves considering the following framework:
Identify the Ethical Issue:
Clearly define the problem or decision.
Gather Information:
Collect relevant facts and perspectives.
Consider Stakeholders:
Identify those affected by the decision.
Explore Alternatives:
Generate and evaluate possible solutions.
Make a Decision:
Choose the option that aligns with ethical principles.
Evaluate the Decision:
Reflect on the outcome and adjust if necessary.
Let’s practice applying this framework to a hypothetical ethical dilemma.
Scenario:
You are the manager of a small team at a tech company. Recently, you discovered that one of your team members, Alex, has been using company resources for personal projects during work hours. Alex is a talented and valued employee, and their personal projects have not yet impacted their performance or team productivity. However, this misuse of company resources violates company policy and, if discovered by upper management, could lead to serious consequences for both Alex and the team.
Applying the Ethical Decision-Making Framework
1. Identify the Ethical Issue
Problem:
Alex is using company resources for personal projects during work hours, violating company policy.
2. Gather Information
Facts:
◦
Alex is a talented and valuable employee.
◦
Alex's personal projects have not yet affected team productivity or performance.
◦
Misuse of company resources violates company policy.
◦
Consequences could include disciplinary action or termination.
Perspectives:
◦
Alex might view the use of resources as harmless since it hasn't affected work performance.
◦
Upper management expects adherence to company policies.
◦
Other team members may perceive this as unfair or may feel they should also be allowed to use company resources similarly.
3. Consider Stakeholders
Alex:
Their job and reputation are at risk.
You (Manager):
Responsibility to enforce policies and maintain fairness.
Team Members:
Their perception of fairness and integrity within the team.
Company/Upper Management:
Expectation of policy adherence and ethical behavior.
4. Explore Alternatives
Option 1:
Address the issue directly with Alex, explain the policy violation, and issue a warning.
Option 2:
Report the violation to upper management and let them handle it.
Option 3:
Allow Alex to continue with a warning to be discreet, risking future issues.
Option 4:
Implement a team-wide reminder of company policies without singling out Alex.
5. Make a Decision
Chosen Option:
Address the issue directly with Alex, explain the policy violation, and issue a warning. Emphasize the importance of adhering to company policies and the potential consequences of continued misuse of resources.
6. Evaluate the Decision
Outcome Reflection:
◦
Monitor Alex's behavior to ensure compliance with company policies.
◦
Ensure team morale remains high and that there is no perception of unfair treatment.
◦
Be prepared to take further action if Alex repeats the behavior.
Adjustments:
◦
Consider setting clearer guidelines or additional training on company policies for all team members.
◦
Evaluate the need for periodic reviews of resource usage to prevent future issues.
Role-Play Exercise
You (Manager):
Hi Alex, do you have a few minutes to talk? I’ve noticed that you’ve been working on personal projects using company resources during work hours. While I appreciate your talent and dedication, this behavior violates our company policy and could lead to serious consequences. I wanted to address this directly with you to give you a chance to correct this before it becomes a bigger issue. Can we discuss how to ensure this doesn’t happen again?
Alex:
I understand, I didn’t realize it was a problem since my work hasn’t been affected. I’ll make sure to stop using company resources for my personal projects. Thank you for bringing this to my attention.
You (Manager):
Thank you for understanding, Alex. It’s important to adhere to our policies to maintain fairness and integrity within the team. Let’s keep an open line of communication, and please let me know if you have any questions or need further clarification on our policies.
Feedback Points:
Clarity and Directness:
◦
Did you clearly define the issue and its implications?
◦
Was the conversation direct but respectful?
Stakeholder Consideration:
◦
Did you consider the perspectives and potential impacts on all stakeholders?
◦
Were the chosen actions fair and ethical?
Follow-Up and Monitoring:
◦
Did you set clear expectations for future behavior?
◦
Have you planned for follow-up and monitoring to ensure compliance?